We Need to Talk About Kevin (2011)
Lynne Ramsay
Synopsis (in chronological order, not as shown in the film)
Opening at Tomatina, a large tomato fight in Valencia successful travel writer Eva is enjoying the prime of her youth and success. Returning home to an American city she falls in love with a wealthier man quickly falling pregnant and is persuaded to take a break from her career to raise their newborn son, Kevin. Initially the child will not stop crying when in the presence and care of its mother whilst remains quiet when father returns home. As a toddler the boy becomes mute in the care of his mother and responds little to her attempts to nurture him resisting the lessons of potty training and good behaviour before Eva resorts to a solitary moment of violent frustration. Their relationship is fractured throughout his young life only taking an interest in his mother reading him The Tales of Robin Hood that fires an enthusiasm for archery spurred on by his doting father. When a younger sister arrives accidentally Kevin resents the girl killing her pet guinea pig and blinding her in one eye. The two parents file for divorce before Kevin kills his father and sister and carries out a massacre at his school approaching his 16th birthday. Eva moves into a smaller house in the area that is pelted with paint along with her car, she gets an entry level job at a travel agents and attempts to avoid the parents of her son’s victims drinking and medicating herself to sleep every night.
Review
From a wide-ranging selection of independent cinema’s most prized ingredients you would expect a dish far more sophisticated than the one ham-fistly presented here. I can only apologise for the food based analogy but for the first half an hour of the film I couldn’t help feeling how over cooked it all seemed to be. The heavy-handed approach to We Need to Talk About Kevin must surely lie at the feet of director Lynne Ramsay, also credited for co-writing the clunky screenplay. The story is a potent tale of an American boy as he grows from maligned infant to sociopathic teenager in episodic flashbacks from his mother’s point of view. Most harrowing aside from his actions is that the usual suspects of blame come into play whilst the writing never allows the complex psychological persuasion of the central character to be explored as uncomfortable moments invite us to find humour in desperately humourless situations.
The film shows snippets of sugar sweet cereal, snatches of the star spangled banner and sketches of schizophrenia, the causes of which are lazily misattributed. It seems as though the script was written scribbling down and sticking with the first visual ideas that popped into the screenwriters heads, substituting the dramatic exploration into an American problem child’s psyche from the novel on which the film is based for obvious and arbitrary judgmental visual statements. It’s as if it was made as a knee-jerk reaction to the Columbine massacre had it happened in the 1980s. “Die! Die! Die!” Kevin sporadically shouts at the screen as he plays on a video game with his loving father. Are we being lectured on the violent nature of video games? “I don’t want to leave the city” insists successful travel writer mother Eva to financially stable father Franklin, sufficiently adequate performances from Tilda Swinton and John C. Reilly respectively, before they whisk their new addition to the family off to the suburbs and a house that strikingly resembles that of Tony Soprano’s - minus one point in the parenting handbook for careerism and the chase of the almighty American dollar. Surprisingly Medieval folklore is even represented in the form of Robin Hood and his exploits in Sherwood Forest with a bow and arrow inspiring Kevin’s preferred means of execution, as though surely we must be wary of the things you feed into our child’s minds.
The only regular stalwarts of bad parenting and characters of subversion that aren’t referenced are music and the movies, and if they are it is with a subtlety that perhaps I missed amongst the onslaught of obvious gestures. The recurring costume choice of a Led Zeppelin t-shirt worn by both mother and father at significant points in their lives was maybe a decision made to somehow link Jimmy Page’s interest in Alistair Crowley and the Occult to the actions of their offspring, however, I would wish to balk at the backwardness of this idea if I thought it was a conscious effort. Never though, as may be expected part way through, do we have Kevin attend a Marilyn Manson concert. Movies on the other hand are only glossed over as mother and daughter, sister of the rampaging Kevin, cosily watch what sounds like a code-era soft gangster flick.
Finally, attention should be drawn to the sound of the film, as it craves attention for the majority of the picture as if for the most part something more interesting is happening out of the frame, usually signified by Tilda Swinton’s forced reactions. When done expertly and this can be a highly effective technique as David Fincher exhibits time and time again. But the volume at which some of the sounds are escalated to in the sound mix is excruciating for all the wrong reasons, when Kevin bites and picks his finger nails or gobbles a lychee that represents the eyeball of his blinded sister – possibly a reference to Un Chien Andalou, if again somewhat awkwardly done – the sound is amplified beyond any kind of proportion. A seemingly schizophrenic soundtrack ties the series of flashbacks together and may have made for interesting listening had it not been so self-consciously attempting to replicate the quirky nature of other 21st century independent films. Perhaps the reason rock bands never come under scrutiny in the films bad parenting blame game the film is scored by Radiohead’s Jonny Greenwood but never reaches the heights scaled by Paul Thomas Anderson’s There Will Be Blood caught as it is between so many different genre signifiers. Thus emblematic of a film where maybe too many cooks have spoiled the broth, or an ambitious yet inept head chef has let her specials menu go awry on a big night in the kitchen.
Review by Matt Henshaw
Movie News & Reviews from University of Leicester Film & Visual Arts students
Showing posts with label matt henshaw. Show all posts
Showing posts with label matt henshaw. Show all posts
Tuesday, 3 January 2012
Thursday, 22 September 2011
Matt Henshaw's Adventures In Wonderland: Road Trip back to Leicester ...
Matt Henshaw's Adventures In Wonderland: Road Trip back to Leicester ...: What a pleasant journey ... What a pleasant city ... What a bloody mare !!! And it was only a quick drop off gangster heist type thi...
Wednesday, 10 August 2011
Thursday, 4 August 2011
Wednesday, 1 June 2011
Scarface (1983) Special Edition DVD – Universal Studios Home Entertainment (2004) under review ...
Scarface (1983) Special Edition DVD – Universal Studios Home Entertainment (2004)
Special Features
- · The Rebirth Of Scarface development featurette
- · Acting Scarface featurette
- · Creating Scarface 'making of' documentary
- · Scarface: The TV Version comparison featurette
- · Deleted scenes (22 mins)
- · Origins Of A Hip-Hop Classic documentary
- · Theatrical and teaser trailers
If ever there was a film that had the kind of cult following that consisted of ever youthful admirers who always wanted to know more about its inception and legacy, and its cast and its creators then Scarface surely is that film. Brian De Palma’s classic film, a successfully remake of an old-time gangster classic, splurges a big fat ink stain in all the suitable boxes and portrays the scurrilous pursuit of the American dream with such a gritty bludgeon like no other film ever has, before or since. Cart-wheeling through hoop after hoop to impress the male psyche we are treated to a melange of guns, breasts and violence, drugs, chainsaws and tigers.
Tony Montana arrives in Miami, Florida, USA from Cuba pronouncing himself as “a political refugee”. He climbs through the cocaine fuelled gangster underworld claiming he wants everything that he’s got coming to him; “the world chico, and everything in it”. It’s a masterfully theatrical performance from Al Pacino who asserts his credence and trustworthiness succinctly, becoming the envy of alpha male and living out a few man’s dreams when he says “I’ve only got two things in this world: my word and my balls, and I don’t break ‘em for nobody” in the face of a South American drug baron. It’s definitely Oliver Stone’s script and Pacino’s portrayal of Montana, both with deftly touched with a subtle hint of humour that endears us to the lead character and the expected demise of Montana leads us to the unexpected sombre ending of his bloodied carcass lying face down in his overblown entrance hall fountain. Were we expected to be sad at the death of our new favourite caricature?
The sets are lavish and the colours are unflinchingly coarse (I’m sure this movie has inspired more than a few ghastly makeovers in those with the taste and mindsets of Delboy Trotter). Producer Martin Bregman had clearly spent greatly to realise the dreams of the Cuban gangster as he reaches the top of the cocaine pyramid; that is symbolised quite literally by a mound of cocaine in one of the closing scenes looks like a snow capped mountain top before Montana throws his face into it.
The soundtrack is a mix of electro 80s chart fodder and Giorgio Moroder’s synth noodlings that run the risk of being overbearing at certain intervals. This can be enjoyed; or not, in Dolby 5.1 surround on the Special Edition DVD. Which brings us nicely the double disc sets special features.
An excellent extra is a short piece on how Universal managed to edit the original film to be suitable for network TV in America. Just how they managed to cope with all the nudity and violence is one thing, but the 160 f-words and the other language is another. There’s also a short from pioneering black record label Def Jam Recordings chronicling the link to rap/hip-hop culture and the 80s movie. There’s the revelation that P Diddy has seen the film 63 times, and it’s probably more since the recording of the interview. We receive a real insight into the funding, production of the film and the method acting style of Al Pacino.
Plus, there’s the usual DVD fodder such as trailers and deleted scenes (that you can’t help but always think “they must have been deleted for a reason, so why show them now?”). But, what is a real treat is the set of shorts that document the making of the film – The Rebirth of Scarface, Acting Scarface and Creating Scrface.
But what this film is really crying out for is a commentary from one or more, or all of the main players. They’re all here on the DVD; sit them in a room together for a few hours and maybe even record their conversation as the film plays. I don’t know?! Even if it takes a few bags of white powder I think it should be done and I’m sure it’s what every die-hard fan would love to hear accompanying their favourite film. No doubt the imminent release of the Blu-Ray edition of the film will be gobbled up with the usual whether this is featured or not. Whatever the case may be, this is a highly entertaining film, and the DVD set includes some highly entertaining extra material.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)